Reuben grilled cheese

Reuben Grilled Cheese: The Ultimate Comfort Food Mashup

Hey there, fellow food adventurer! If you’ve ever found yourself torn between craving a gooey grilled cheese and a hearty Reuben sandwich, let me introduce you to your new kitchen BFF: the Reuben Grilled Cheese. Imagine the best parts of a classic deli Reuben—smoky pastrami, tangy sauerkraut, Swiss cheese that oozes like a hug—all smashed between two slices of golden, buttery rye bread. This isn’t just a sandwich; it’s a flavor fireworks show disguised as comfort food.

Picture this: It’s raining outside, your sweatpants are on point, and you need a meal that’s equal parts cozy and exciting. That’s where this mashup shines. It’s quicker than assembling a traditional Reuben (no layering six ingredients taller than your coffee mug), but it’s got all the attitude of the original. Plus, dipping each bite into creamy Thousand Island dressing? Game. Changer.

I’ll let you in on a secret: This recipe was born during a “fridge raid” moment. You know, when hunger and laziness collide? But the result was so stupidly good, it’s now in my regular rotation. Let’s get your skillet sizzling!

The Deli Counter That Started It All

My love affair with Reubens began at 10 years old, wedged into a vinyl booth at Louie’s Lower East Side Deli. My grandpa—a man who believed mustard was a food group—ordered me a Reuben “for the grown-up palate.” I took one bite and… hated it. Too sour! Too weird! But Grandpa just grinned. “Try again when your taste buds evolve, kiddo.”

Fast-forward to college: I’m broke, it’s 2 a.m., and my roommate’s heating up canned sauerkraut. The smell teleported me back to Louie’s. Next day, I cobbled together a Reuben-inspired grilled cheese with dorm fridge scraps. No artisanal rye? Wheat bread worked. No Swiss? Cheddar pretended. That first melty, messy bite? A revelation. Now, every time I make this sandwich, I toast Grandpa (and that thrifty roommate) with a pickle spear.

Ingredients: Building Your Flavor Bomb

Makes 2 knock-your-socks-off sandwiches

• 4 slices rye bread – The caraway seeds add a subtle spice. No rye? Sourdough’s tang works too!
• ½ lb pastrami – Look for thinly sliced. Corned beef’s a great swap if you’re Team Brine.
• 1 cup Swiss cheese – Shred it yourself for maximum melt. Gruyère adds a nutty upgrade.
• ½ cup sauerkraut – Drain it like your sanity depends on it. Wet kraut = soggy bread. Trust me.
• 2 tbsp butter – Softened. Mayo-haters, you can use mayo for extra crisp (I won’t tell).
• ¼ cup Thousand Island – Store-bought or make your own in 2 minutes flat.

Let’s Get Grilling: Your Roadmap to Melty Glory

Step 1: Butter your bread like it’s a sunbathing celebrity. Outside slices only—this is the golden rule of grilled cheese. Pro tip: Let butter soften at room temp for easy spreading. Cold butter tears bread. Sadness ensues.

Step 2: Layer like a flavor architect. On the unbuttered side: cheese (half on each slice!), pastrami, kraut, dressing. Cheese on both sides? Yes! It acts as glue against saucy rebellion.

Step 3: Medium heat is your friend. Too hot = burnt outside, cold inside. Low and slow wins the race. Cover the skillet for the last minute to turbo-melt the cheese.

Step 4: Resist cutting immediately! Let it rest 60 seconds. This lets the cheese settle, preventing a lava-like cheese eruption (tasty but hazardous).

🥪 Serving Suggestions: Take Your Reuben Grilled Cheese from Good to Glorious

So you’ve got your Reuben Grilled Cheese—hot off the skillet, golden brown, oozing Swiss, and smelling like a New York deli dream. What now? Let’s make this a full-on experience, not just a sandwich on a plate. From classic deli-style pairings to bold twists, here’s how to serve your melty masterpiece like a total sandwich boss.

---

🥒 The Classic Deli Spread

When in doubt, go old-school. The Reuben is a deli legend, so serve it with sides that would make any sandwich artist proud.

• Garlic Dill Pickles – Crunchy, tangy, and cold—the perfect contrast to a warm, cheesy sandwich. Spears, chips, or whole baby dills work. Bonus points for homemade.

• Potato Chips – Thick-cut kettle chips, salt-and-vinegar, or even BBQ. Let ‘em ride shotgun on the plate or tuck a few into the sandwich. (Trust me.)

• Creamy Coleslaw – A refreshing, crunchy side that cuts through the richness. Go classic or add apple slices for a sweet twist.

• Tomato Soup Shooter – Serve a warm, velvety shot of tomato soup on the side for dipping. Unexpected, but incredible.

---

🍻 Drink Pairings to Sip Between Bites

Balance that salty, cheesy goodness with something cool and crisp.

• Iced Dill Pickle Lemonade – Sounds weird. Tastes amazing. Tart, refreshing, and a little salty—it matches the sandwich’s punch.

• Citrusy IPA or Dark Lager – A craft beer with bite pairs beautifully with pastrami’s smoky richness.

• Crisp Apple Cider – The sweet-tart notes play well with Swiss and kraut.

• Sparkling Water with Lemon or Cucumber – Keep it light and fizzy if you want the sandwich to stay center stage.

---

🥗 Want to Lighten It Up? Pair with Fresh Greens

If you’re looking to balance out the indulgence, add a crisp salad alongside your Reuben grilled cheese. Some ideas:

• Baby Arugula Salad – Toss with lemon vinaigrette and shaved parmesan. Peppery greens + melty cheese = yes.

• German Potato Salad – Served warm, with vinegar and bacon. It mirrors the tang of the kraut and adds heartiness.

• Roasted Beet and Goat Cheese Salad – For a bold, earthy-sweet contrast.

---

🍳 Turn It Into a Full-On Brunch or Dinner Plate

This sandwich has range! Here’s how to make it shine across meals:

• Brunch: Add a fried egg on top and serve with crispy hash browns and a Bloody Mary.

• Dinner: Cut the sandwich into halves or quarters, serve with a pickle-topped salad and roasted carrots or Brussels sprouts.

• Late Night: Keep it simple. Sandwich, chips, soda, TV. Comfort doesn’t need frills.

---

🧁 Sweet Endings (Because Why Not?)

Cap it off with a little treat:

• Black-and-White Cookie – A nod to NYC delis.

• Chocolate-Dipped Pretzels – Sweet + salty = perfect send-off.

• Mini Cheesecake Bites – Tangy and rich, just like the sandwich.

Mix It Up: 5 Twists to Try

• The Rachel: Swap pastrami for turkey, sauerkraut for coleslaw
• Spicy Reuben: Add pickled jalapeños or sriracha to the dressing
• Vegan Vibes: Use plant-based cheese, mushroom “pastrami,” and vegan mayo dressing
• Breakfast Reuben: Add a fried egg and swap dressing for hollandaise
• Pretzel Bread: For extra crunch and a salty kick

Chef’s Confessions & Kitchen Mishaps

True story: I once used marble rye (those swirly ones) and the sandwich looked like a tie-dye mess. Tasted amazing, but my Instagram followers roasted me for a week. Lesson learned: Keep bread simple, save swirls for brunch.

Over the years, I’ve learned: 1) Squish the kraut with paper towels—no exceptions. 2) A cast-iron skillet gives the best crust. 3) If the cheese leaks, it’s not a mistake—it’s “crispy cheese lace.” Sell it with confidence.

FAQs: Your Sandwich Queries, Solved

Q: My bread burns before the cheese melts! Help!
A: Lower the heat! Medium-low is the sweet spot. Cover the skillet to trap heat, melting cheese faster.

Q: Can I use pre-shredded cheese?
A: Sure, but it won’t melt as smoothly. Pre-shredded cheese has anti-caking agents. For silky ooze, shred your own!

Q: How do I keep it from getting soggy?
A: Drain kraut thoroughly, and don’t overdo the dressing. A thin layer (1 tbsp per sandwich) is plenty.

Q: Can I air-fry this?
A: Absolutely! 370°F for 6-8 minutes, flipping halfway. Spritz bread with oil instead of butter.

Nutritional Info (Per Serving)

Calories: 480 | Fat: 30g | Carbs: 28g | Protein: 26g
Note: Values are estimates. Want it lighter? Use low-fat cheese and turkey pastrami.

Print

🧀 Final Thoughts: A Melty Mashup Worth Repeating

At the end of the day, the Reuben Grilled Cheese isn’t just a sandwich—it’s a full-blown comfort food celebration. It brings together the best of two classics: the nostalgic warmth of grilled cheese and the bold, briny punch of a Reuben. And the result? Pure magic between two crispy, buttery slices of rye.

What makes this recipe so special isn’t just the ingredients—it’s the feeling. It’s the cozy vibes on a rainy day. It’s the joy of turning leftovers into something epic. It’s the first bite when the cheese stretches, the pastrami’s still warm, and that zing of sauerkraut cuts through the richness like a culinary mic drop.

This sandwich is fast, forgiving, and endlessly customizable. You can dress it up with fancy cheese and bakery rye or dress it down with fridge staples and a skillet that’s seen better days—it still delivers. It’s the kind of meal you can whip up in 15 minutes, but it tastes like you planned it all week.

So whether you’re feeding a crowd, nursing a craving, or just looking for something that hits all the right notes—crispy, melty, savory, tangy—this Reuben Grilled Cheese has your back. And hey, if you accidentally burn the first one while dancing in your kitchen? Call it a warm-up round.

From deli memories to midnight cravings, this sandwich has earned its place in the comfort food hall of fame. So go ahead, grab that skillet, butter that bread, and get toasting. Because the best meals aren’t always fancy—they’re just damn good.